Coliving Pulse #015 — What a Consent Costs, and a City That Won Its Co-Living Case and Backed Down Anyway
Published · Hüseyin Şanlıtürk
Contents
Issue fifteen covers 7 to 16 November — nine days rather than seven, because there was no issue on Saturday. One limitation to declare before anything else: our feed retains roughly four days of items, so the early part of that window is thinner than the rest, and anything that broke on 7 or 8 November and was not picked up elsewhere is simply not in front of us. We would rather say that than present nine days as evenly covered.
Sutton: the £1.5m that issue fourteen could not find
Last issue we reported Sutton Council's approval of St Nicholas House — a former 12-storey office becoming a 359-unit coliving scheme at 15 storeys, approved under delegated powers after more than 100 representations in support and one objection — and we noted explicitly that affordable housing, Section 106 and planning obligations were not mentioned anywhere we could read. That gap has now closed, nine days later.
BTR News reports, under today's date, that JRL Group and Halcyon Development Partners have agreed a £1.5m affordable housing contribution for the scheme, and that "the planning agreement for St Nicholas House sets out a series of financial and community commitments linked to the development". That sentence is the standfirst, and it is as far as we could read: the body is behind a registration wall, and no other outlet we could reach carries the story. So this is one source, read to the second sentence.
What that means for what follows. We cannot tell you whether the £1.5m is a commuted sum paid instead of on-site affordable accommodation or a contribution alongside some on-site provision, whether it is a Section 106 obligation or something else, when it becomes payable, or what the other "financial and community commitments" are. Those are not footnotes. The difference between a payment in lieu and on-site provision is the whole substance of an affordable housing position.
One piece of arithmetic, and we are doing it rather than reporting it, because it joins two sources: £1.5m set against the 359 units we verified last issue is about £4,200 a unit. We are not going to tell you whether that is low, because to say so we would need Sutton's own policy target and the viability case behind the agreement, and we read neither. The useful version of the question is the one an operator can act on: a 359-unit scheme on a town-centre site has settled its affordable housing position for a single seven-figure payment, and the thing worth finding out is what 359 conventional homes on the same site would have carried.
Hackney: 490 units, 35 storeys, three votes for and four abstentions
Hackney Council's planning committee approved the Finsgate House scheme on the evening of 11 November: a 35-storey tower of 490 coliving units for developer HUB, designed by AHMM, replacing three 1980s office buildings near the Old Street roundabout, with a separate five-storey block of 4,000 sq m of workspace alongside. Each floor of the tower will typically hold 18 self-contained studios. No completion timetable has been set out.
The vote is the part to keep. Three councillors voted in favour and four abstained. Nobody voted against. A 35-storey tower carried by a minority of the committee with the rest declining to express a view is a different political fact from an enthusiastic approval, and it sits oddly beside the pattern we drew last issue, where a dead office block attracted a hundred supportive representations and one objection. Sutton's site had no constituency. This one has a committee that would not say no and would not say yes either.
Two discrepancies between the two reports we could read, both small, both the kind of thing we would rather flag than smooth over. The Architects' Journal describes the workspace as 4,000 sq m of "affordable workspace"; Urban Living News describes the same 4,000 sq m as "Grade A workspace". Those are not the same planning commitment, and we do not know which is right. And the street is "Cranbrook Street" in one account and "Cranwood Street" in the other. Hackney's planning pages carry no committee record we could reach, so we have no application reference to settle either point.
A third headline from the same day — "Green light for 490-home Hackney co-living scheme" — almost certainly describes this same consent, on the matching unit count and borough, but the publisher refuses our requests so we could not open it and confirm. Last issue two headlines turned out to be one consent; the check that caught it was mechanical, and we ran it again here. One scheme, three headlines.
Shawnee, Kansas: the city won, and is loosening anyway
We went after this story expecting a third regulatory pattern — regulation by lawsuit, as against England's regulation by plan. That is not what happened, and the real sequence is more interesting than the one we expected.
Shawnee, a city in Johnson County, Kansas, adopted an ordinance in April 2022 by a 7-0 vote which, as the local reporting puts it, "effectively limited the number of unrelated individuals who can live together in a single living space to three". It was aimed at companies buying houses for room-by-room letting. In May 2023 a Shawnee resident and HomeRoom, Inc., a property management company, sued in federal court with the Pacific Legal Foundation, arguing the city had exceeded its zoning authority by writing a rule that "regulates only people" rather than land. They sought an injunction, not damages.
The city won. The district court dismissed the case in September 2023, holding that HomeRoom, as a corporate entity, had no constitutionally protected right of intimate association and could not assert its tenants' rights. The Tenth Circuit affirmed the dismissal, reported on 7 April 2026, with the observation that "Belle Terre remains good law and is binding authority" — a reference to the 1974 Supreme Court case upholding a zoning ordinance limiting unrelated occupants in a dwelling. The city attorney says the Supreme Court then declined to take the case, which we have not checked against a court docket.
Then, on Monday 9 November, with the litigation over and the ordinance upheld, the Shawnee Council Committee directed staff to draft amendments loosening it — raising the cap from three unrelated occupants to four, and removing the provision that classifies a whole household as unrelated if a single unrelated adult lives there. Anything above four would still be treated as a co-living group and still be illegal. The reasons councillors gave were about housing, not about law. Councilmember Jeanie Murphy: "While (it's) legal, in this time of housing shortages and people not being able to afford housing, I don't know if it's the kindest way to deal with our residents." Councilmember Erin Aldridge: "I think putting this kind of restriction is an overreach." The litigation cost the city about $27,000.
Three things to be precise about. This is a committee direction, not law: the amendments must go to the Shawnee Planning Commission, expected in December or early 2027, before the council can vote. The change is from three people to four — one person, after a four-year federal fight. And the rule everyone calls a co-living ban is not a co-living rule at all; it is a generic cap on unrelated occupants, and the courts treated it as exactly that, resting on a precedent from 1974. We could not reach the ordinance text or the committee motion, so all of the above is from the local paper's reporting rather than from a city document.
The thread: the obligation is where the start dies
Issue fourteen's finding was that consent is not the constraint. Savills had BTR starts down 63 per cent in the year to September against completions up 21 per cent, with consented units slightly up — a funnel narrowing between permission and commencement rather than before permission. We said the binding constraint sits in that gap and named viability, rent-control speculation and Building Safety Regulator delays.
This week adds the item we left out of that list, because it was the one we could not see: the obligation. Sutton's consent carries £1.5m. Hackney's carries 4,000 sq m of workspace and whatever else the committee attached before three of its members would vote for it. These are the costs that land on an appraisal after the consent is won and before the ground is broken, and they are negotiated in exactly the stretch of the funnel where the starts are disappearing. We are not claiming the obligations caused the fall; we have one scheme's figure read to a standfirst and no viability case. We are saying that if you want to know why a consented English coliving scheme has not started, the Section 106 is the document to read, and it is the one the trade press reports last and least.
Set the American story against it and the two regimes separate cleanly. England is writing coliving-specific policy — room sizes, amenity, management plans, and a price. The United States, in Shawnee at least, has no coliving policy whatsoever; it has a fifty-year-old occupancy precedent, and the instrument available to an operator is federal litigation. One regime charges money and grants permission. The other charges years and, having won, moved by one person.
The limit on that comparison, stated plainly: Shawnee is one suburban city of a few tens of thousands, and we are using it to characterise a national regime it does not represent. What it does establish is narrower and still worth having — that in the US the thing standing between a room-by-room letting model and a residential street may be a 1974 zoning case rather than anything written about coliving at all.
What we are watching
The St Nicholas House planning agreement itself. Whether the £1.5m replaces on-site affordable provision is the question the headline does not answer, and it decides what the number means. If anyone can reach Sutton's planning register, that is where it is.
Whether Finsgate House starts, and when. A 35-storey tower approved by three votes out of seven, with no completion timetable, is a good test of issue fourteen's thesis in a single building.
The Shawnee Planning Commission in December or early 2027, and whether three-to-four survives to a council vote. A committee direction has died at that stage before.
Whether any English council refuses a coliving application under a coliving policy it has adopted. We have been watching for this since issue twelve and it has not happened yet; policy is tested at the first refusal, not at adoption.
A note on this issue
There was no issue on Saturday 14 November, and this one lands on Monday 16th. Issue fourteen said we would stop narrating the calendar, so instead of explaining it again we have changed the thing that kept being wrong: this page and the feed no longer promise a particular day. The Pulse is weekly, the archive shows exactly when each issue appeared, and a claim we can keep is worth more than a better-sounding one we cannot.

Written by
Hüseyin Şanlıtürk
Founder of StartColiving. Eight-plus years in hospitality and growth marketing, applied to coliving — we build and grow coliving brands, and we built our own marketplace, Rentser.
Published About the author →How we source this →
Sources
- BTR News — JRL and Halcyon agree £1.5m affordable housing contribution for Sutton co-living scheme (16 November 2026), by Bea Patel; sole source, read only to the standfirst because the body is behind a registration wall ↗
- The Architects' Journal — AHMM gets go-ahead for 35-storey Old Street co-living tower (12 November 2026), by Gino Spocchia; Hackney planning committee decision of 11 November 2026, three votes in favour and four abstentions ↗
- Urban Living News — HUB gets green light for Hoxton coliving tower (12 November 2026), by George Sell; same consent as the Architects' Journal report above ↗
- Johnson County Post — Shawnee moves to ease co-living ban that sparked lawsuit, national headlines (13 November 2026), by Andrew Gaug; committee direction of 9 November 2026, not adopted law ↗
- Johnson County Post — Federal appeals court upholds Shawnee's controversial co-living ban (7 April 2026), by Andrew Gaug; Tenth Circuit affirmation of the September 2023 district court dismissal ↗
- Johnson County Post — Federal lawsuit challenges Shawnee's co-living ban (10 May 2023), by Kaylie McLaughlin; the complaint, plaintiffs and grounds ↗
Growing a coliving brand?
We run growth for 18+ coliving brands — and built our own marketplace.
Book a Free Strategy CallKeep reading
Coliving Pulse #014 — BTR Starts Fell 63% While Completions Rose 21%, and Consent Is Not the Constraint
Read →
Coliving Pulse #013 — Seoul Has No Legal Category for Coliving, and Morgan Stanley, GIC and CPP Are Already In
Read →
Coliving Pulse #012 — Councils Are Writing Coliving Into Policy While Closing the Door on Converted HMOs
Read →